Anachronous Rex
New Member
Mayhaps, but when dealing with people in a conversational setting - or in the context of this forum - they are of almost no use.impiku said:You can call it herd-mentality if you like, but I construe it more positively. Political labels just roughly outline one's political values, expecting it to perfectly describe a person is asinine. I would rather much prefer labels than enumerating a multitude of policies and beliefs to demonstrate my values, categorization saves time. Labels help identify and align people towards a common political goal. I believe it is significant.Anachronous Rex said:Though while we're on the subject: I also find that people who spend a lot of time fixating on labels really tend to wear out their welcome very fast. Especially so when the "you must just think that way because you're an x" thing enters into play.
Observe:
You call yourself a libertarian. Immediately I am slightly unnerved, but only because I have known many 'libertarians' who cling to the moniker only to emphasize disdain for the principal two parties of the American republic, with little actual understanding of the stance's policies or consequences. Still others do understand possess a functional understanding of the libertarian position (sometimes even a quite advanced understanding), but are - if you'll excuse my being crude about it - inept or naive when it comes to application and implementation, and employ a sort of magical thinking with regards to how things will just work out on their own; completely oblivious to the possibility of a failed state. Finally there are, the most painful of all groups, those whose view of libertarianism borders on Anarcho-capitalism, and who may in fact be closeted or oblivious Anarcho-capitalists.
All of these people are morons, but I also know people who call themselves libertarian who are well thought out, intelligent, and responsible. People I would vote for if they ran for local office or somesuch. Hell, I'd even vote for some of them on a national scale.
Now which one are you? The label is of no use to me here, I'd have to actually know your stance on real issues to make any judgment as to your person. The same applies to most labels, save for a very rare category of positions that do not allow for dissidence, and do not tolerate it in their midst.
"What do you believe and why?" is all I bother to ask these days.