Mugnuts said:Three books written by Carrier about his Jesus Study.
Three books all with sources and citations after years of research.
The position that Carrier holds is not just his own so how you can state that underlined portion doesn't fly.
Have you had the chance to read any of the books? I presume obviously not or you wouldn't have said the above.
FYI, watching a few Carrier videos will not detail his case, hence reading them might give you more of an informed opinion.
You are correct, I have not read his books, but it is on my todo list. That being said, his conclusion would still be conjecture. He is working on incomplete information. The region where Yeshua supposedly lived has been war torn for centuries. A lot of the evidence may be lost forever. We may never know for certain whether or not the historical Jesus existed. More evidence may surface in the future or maybe no further evidence will surface.