Dragan Glas
Well-Known Member
Re: Irreducible complexity and other creationist talking poi
Greetings,
Independent and codependent are not necessarily the same thing.
Mutations may need to be present at the same time but they don't have to occur at the same time.
Kindest regards,
James
Greetings,
Wrong. Non-lethal ones - whether beneficial or neutral - are passed on.leroy said:By definition only beneficial changes can be selected by natural selection, (sure other mechanism like genetic drift can select neutral and negative changes)Dragan Glas said:No, they don't - as my posts on the previous page, along with the linked threads, explained.
No, they don't have to occur in one generation - generations can go by without any relevant mutation occurring.leroy said:Evolution is suppose to work on the basis of building and selection upon mutations, each individual mutation occur in 1 generation, this is what I mean, we simply mean something different with “change”Dragan Glas said:But they don't have to occur in one generation - as my posts on the previous page, along with the linked threads, explained.
You're switching between evolution and natural selection - it's all just evolution.leroy said:For natural selection to select 2 independent and codependent mutations they have to occur at the same time.Dragan Glas said:No, they don't - as my posts on the previous page, along with the linked threads, explained.
If you what to invoke other mechanisms (like genetic drift) then these mutations can occur at different times.
Independent and codependent are not necessarily the same thing.
Mutations may need to be present at the same time but they don't have to occur at the same time.
Kindest regards,
James