• Welcome to League Of Reason Forums! Please read the rules before posting.
    If you are willing and able please consider making a donation to help with site overheads.
    Donations can be made via here

The death penalty

arg-fallbackName="SpecialFrog"/>
Thenexttodie, Europe possibly has more beards than the US. This statement is as much of a non-sequitur as yours as it has no bearing on whether or not racism impacts the application of the death penalty in the US.
 
arg-fallbackName="thenexttodie"/>
he_who_is_nobody said:
thenexttodie said:
Europeans are way more racist than Americans are.

citaton-needed.png

Europeans are so racist, white Europeans are even racist against other white Europeans. No one who has spent a significant amount of time living and working in the E.U. can honestly deny this. I have a black guy working under me right now who would probably be my boss if we were in the US. He will never be promoted. The reason why no empirical study exists which I could cite is because everyone knows it is true. Europe is a great to place to go to experience racism.
 
arg-fallbackName="thenexttodie"/>
SpecialFrog said:
Thenexttodie, Europe possibly has more beards than the US. This statement is as much of a non-sequitur as yours as it has no bearing on whether or not racism impacts the application of the death penalty in the US.

What's your point? Blacks are more often sentenced to death than whites are for fucking murdering people in the past 50 years or some fucking bullshit? And so you are worried that death penalty might be racist, or that racist ideas might infect the minds of jurors faced with a death penalty case? Some pussy bullshit like that, is what your worried about right? How about we just take all murderers and line them up against a wall and fucking shoot them all? Sounds good to me. Would that be racist?
 
arg-fallbackName="SpecialFrog"/>
Thenexttodie, you might get peoples points if you actually read what they said instead of arguing against pretend positions.
 
arg-fallbackName="he_who_is_nobody"/>
thenexttodie said:
he_who_is_nobody said:

Europeans are so racist, white Europeans are even racist against other white Europeans. No one who has spent a significant amount of time living and working in the E.U. can honestly deny this. I have a black guy working under me right now who would probably be my boss if we were in the US. He will never be promoted. The reason why no empirical study exists which I could cite is because everyone knows it is true. Europe is a great to place to go to experience racism.

plural-anecdote.jpg
 
arg-fallbackName="nemesiss"/>
how would a death penalty fit in a judicial system, where people after they paid for their crime, will return to society?
Then obviously, the only good reason for a death penalty is when it is proven impossible to return that said person to society.
But...

what would "impossible to return to society" mean?
would it be that said person would commit crimes the moment he or she steps out of prison?
how severe would that crime(s) have to be?
how could you even demonstrate it?
how is it better then life imprisonment?

and there probably more questions we need to answer before we can truly justify the death penalty.
But then you have to ask questions like

How will you execute that said person?
Where will it be performed?
How will perform the execution?
What it said method cannot be used?


Thus, the best of course of action is not to use the death penalty...
 
arg-fallbackName="Dragan Glas"/>
Greetings,
thenexttodie said:
SpecialFrog said:
Thenexttodie, Europe possibly has more beards than the US. This statement is as much of a non-sequitur as yours as it has no bearing on whether or not racism impacts the application of the death penalty in the US.
What's your point? Blacks are more often sentenced to death than whites are for fucking murdering people in the past 50 years or some fucking bullshit?
There are studies which show the discrepancy between sentencing in general, nevermind when the death penalty is on the table.

This is nost "some fucking bullshit"
thenexttodie said:
And so you are worried that death penalty might be racist, or that racist ideas might infect the minds of jurors faced with a death penalty case? Some pussy bullshit like that, is what your worried about right?
Yes, we're referring to, and are concerned about, that.

"Some pussy bullshit like that" is exactly what we're concerned about.

This is where racism has its ultimate effect - where the life of a person is at stake.
thenexttodie said:
How about we just take all murderers and line them up against a wall and fucking shoot them all? Sounds good to me. Would that be racist?
How is this in keeping with the Christian message of compassion? Of "forgive and forget"?

Kindest regards,

James
 
arg-fallbackName="thenexttodie"/>
thenexttodie said:
How about we just take all murderers and line them up against a wall and fucking shoot them all? Sounds good to me. Would that be racist?
Dragan Glas said:
How is this in keeping with the Christian message of compassion? Of "forgive and forget"?

How do you forgive a murderer?
 
arg-fallbackName="Mr_Wilford"/>
thenexttodie said:
thenexttodie said:
How about we just take all murderers and line them up against a wall and fucking shoot them all? Sounds good to me. Would that be racist?
Dragan Glas said:
How is this in keeping with the Christian message of compassion? Of "forgive and forget"?

How do you forgive a murderer?

Didn't Jesus forgive those who crucified him?
 
arg-fallbackName="SpecialFrog"/>
thenexttodie said:
How do you forgive a murderer?
Have you actually read the Bible?
Matthew 6:14 said:
For if you forgive people their failures your heavenly Father will forgive you; but if you do not forgive people their failures neither will your heavenly Father forgive yours.
 
arg-fallbackName="WarK"/>
thenexttodie said:
thenexttodie said:
How do you forgive a murderer?

itsdemtitans said:
Didn't Jesus forgive those who crucified him?

Are you saying we can only forgive are own murderers or can we forgive some one who murders someone else?

Dude, where did you get this from? What part of his question made you ask yours? Seriously, it wasn't even 10 words and you came up with that?
Mind boggling.
 
arg-fallbackName="Dragan Glas"/>
Greetings,
thenexttodie said:
thenexttodie said:
How about we just take all murderers and line them up against a wall and fucking shoot them all? Sounds good to me. Would that be racist?
Dragan Glas said:
How is this in keeping with the Christian message of compassion? Of "forgive and forget"?

How do you forgive a murderer?
The same way you forgive anyone - by having compassion for others.

You're assuming that someone who kills is "evil".

Until you understand why they've killed someone, you're in no position to judge them.

They could be suffering from mental health problems or been brought up in violence (crime families) or have been misled (like suicide bombers, for instance) or are unable to control their temper (the proverbial "red mist" resulting in a "hot-blooded" crime).

Kindest regards,

James
 
arg-fallbackName="Mr_Wilford"/>
thenexttodie said:
thenexttodie said:
How do you forgive a murderer?

itsdemtitans said:
Didn't Jesus forgive those who crucified him?

Are you saying we can only forgive are own murderers or can we forgive some one who murders someone else?

I cringed.

We can forgive murderers, be they ours or others. Just this past month here in the US, a pastor's wife, pregnant with his daughter, was shot and killed. You can read the rest of the story here.

Wanna know what he had to say?
"Though everything inside of me wants to hate, be angry, and slip into despair I choose the route of forgiveness, grace and hope."

He chose to forgive the man who killed his wife and unborn child, despite how much he wanted to be hateful, because that's what God did for us.

Or do you think being a Christian mean you can accept God's forgiveness of your trespasses but you can just hold a grudge against anyone else's?
 
arg-fallbackName="thenexttodie"/>
thenexttodie said:
How do you forgive a murderer?
Dragan Glas said:
The same way you forgive anyone - by having compassion for others.

You're assuming that someone who kills is "evil".


I'm talking about about murderers. I know this will probably blow your mind but it is possible to kill someone without murdering them.

So say someone murders your wife. Or someone elses wife. Or someones child. Show me how we can have forgiveness.
 
arg-fallbackName="Dragan Glas"/>
Greetings,
thenexttodie said:
thenexttodie said:
How do you forgive a murderer?
Dragan Glas said:
The same way you forgive anyone - by having compassion for others.

You're assuming that someone who kills is "evil".
I'm talking about about murderers. I know this will probably blow your mind but it is possible to kill someone without murdering them.

So say someone murders your wife. Or someone elses wife. Or someones child. Show me how we can have forgiveness.
As I said, by understanding the reasons why they committed murder or, indeed, any other crime.

Criminologists have pointed out that people aren't evil - all that's needed is the right circumstances.

Kindest regards,

James
 
arg-fallbackName="thenexttodie"/>
itsdemtitans said:
We can forgive murderers, be they ours or others. Just this past month here in the US, a pastor's wife, pregnant with his daughter, was shot and killed. You can read the rest of the story here.

Wanna know what he had to say?
"Though everything inside of me wants to hate, be angry, and slip into despair I choose the route of forgiveness, grace and hope."

He chose to forgive the man who killed his wife and unborn child, despite how much he wanted to be hateful, because that's what God did for us.

Do you think that this man would have said this if it meant that his wife's murderer would then be set free to go unpunished? And if so, how would this fit with any rational justice system? No, this man has no authority to forgive his wifes murderer. In the same way I cannot forgive a person who stole $100 from you.
 
arg-fallbackName="Dragan Glas"/>
Greetings,
thenexttodie said:
itsdemtitans said:
We can forgive murderers, be they ours or others. Just this past month here in the US, a pastor's wife, pregnant with his daughter, was shot and killed. You can read the rest of the story here.

Wanna know what he had to say?

"Though everything inside of me wants to hate, be angry, and slip into despair I choose the route of forgiveness, grace and hope."

He chose to forgive the man who killed his wife and unborn child, despite how much he wanted to be hateful, because that's what God did for us.
Do you think that this man would have said this if it meant that his wife's murderer would then be set free to go unpunished? And if so, how would this fit with any rational justice system? No, this man has no authority to forgive his wifes murderer. In the same way I cannot forgive a person who stole $100 from you.
"Authority"?

Who is the better person here - him or you?

"Judge not lest ye be judged".

Kindest regards,

James
 
Back
Top