D
Deleted member 619
Guest
Oh, I meant to add:
This notion that the laws of thought, often referred to as the laws of logic, are absolute, and require accounting, is asinine.
Like reason and science, the laws of thought are pragmatic. Could they be wrong? Dunno, and nor does anybody else. What they actually are are descriptions of how we think about things, and specifically about contradictions. We think, based on a large body of evidence, that contradictions can't obtain in the real world. We work on that basis, and will continue to do so, because that basis works. The point at which we'll stop taking them as absolute is the point at which we encounter a contradiction.
The entire basis for the presupp position on 'logical absolutes' is rooted in a fundamental misunderstanding of what they actually are. They don't require explanation. Things are what they are, and we've found no instance of something being what it is and simultaneously not what it is. When we find one, we'll ditch the LNC and the LOI.
Again, they work. That's it. No presupposition or explanatory basis required.
This notion that the laws of thought, often referred to as the laws of logic, are absolute, and require accounting, is asinine.
Like reason and science, the laws of thought are pragmatic. Could they be wrong? Dunno, and nor does anybody else. What they actually are are descriptions of how we think about things, and specifically about contradictions. We think, based on a large body of evidence, that contradictions can't obtain in the real world. We work on that basis, and will continue to do so, because that basis works. The point at which we'll stop taking them as absolute is the point at which we encounter a contradiction.
The entire basis for the presupp position on 'logical absolutes' is rooted in a fundamental misunderstanding of what they actually are. They don't require explanation. Things are what they are, and we've found no instance of something being what it is and simultaneously not what it is. When we find one, we'll ditch the LNC and the LOI.
Again, they work. That's it. No presupposition or explanatory basis required.