PIE VS CAKE: What will you choose?

[Procrastinator]

Ok, here's the story,
There are some people who like pie and some people who like cake. I am a pie person. My friend, cake person. This debate has been going on for a long time and we really want to know, which is better: pie or cake?
Vote now!

 

[Ozymandyus]

Well, first of all I like all cakes and Pies.... I'm not some discriminatory bastard like you seem to be. You should be ASHAMED of yourself.

Secondly, if you allow for all forms of Pie, but you have to separate out ice-cream cake and don't talk about all the forms of cake it seems like you may be biasing the results. I bet you wouldn't let cakes vote if it were up to you. You think they are less than human DON'T you?! ADMIT IT!

 

[Procrastinator]

Excuse me? I do let cakes vote, its just that ice-cream cake is made of ice-cream and I think(and hopefully everyone agrees) that ice-cream should never be argued over. Thats why I put it in as a third option.

 

[Ozymandyus]

OH SURE, but you talk specifically about allowing ALL forms of pie, and don't talk about allowing ALL forms of cake! Just for that, I'm including dirt pie, worm pie and bug pie! EWWW PIE SUCKS!

I am totally kidding by the way. You might take your pie a bit too seriously.

 

[Procrastinator]

So your saying that you eat dirt pie, bug pie and worm pie?
I'm talking about pies and cakes that you eat, you know that have a recipe or you can actually buy, not something you make while gardening

 

[Ozymandyus]

So your saying that you eat dirt pie, bug pie and worm pie?
I'm talking about pies and cakes that you eat, you know that have a recipe or you can actually buy, not something you make while gardening

'when voting take into account all forms of pie- sweet and savoury)' You didn't tell me to take into account only pies I eat!

All I am saying is that you placed unequal emphasis on Pie - it is clear which you favor by the way to ask the question and what you place emphasis on (though you did also mention it). For example you didn't say 'when voting take into account all forms of cake, carrot, cake with fillings, cakes with different icings etc!'

You are biasing the results! I was just trying to say it in a fun way but if we want to be serious... I understand. Pie and Cake is srs bsnss.

 

[Synystyr]

At least the choices aren't "yes" and "no".


Mmmm tangy apple pie. I'm not a huge sweets guy but apple pie rules my domain.

 

[COMMUNIST FLISK]

BOTH

OM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM NOM

 

[ediblenapalm]

I'm fat, so both.

 

[enterman]

Cake will always win this war. Nothing can stop the all powerful cake, NOTHING.

 

[WizardofCalculus]

Is this between you and flipflops?


Pie is far superior. Cake isn't bad, but I like pie. Pie is wonderful, and has such a large variety. But ice cream cake is wonderful, and cake is not bad, and I do enjoy eating like, half a cake once a year, but after that I'm caked out. Then feed me pie.


(or baklava)

 

[GoodKat]

The cake is a... ahh nevermind.

 

[irmerk]

I did it for the nookie. Cookie sounds like nookie. Cookies are almost a cake. Cake.