Since we were derailing the homeopathy thread and organic farming will probably provoke some interesting discussion, I thought it would be a good idea to start a new thread.
Organic farming is basically farming without using synthetic chemicals, fertilisers, or organisms (i.e., GMOs). The idea is to use natural alternatives which are supposedly better in some way. From my point of view organic farming is one big naturalistic fallacy. (*It doesn't refer to C's and H's, stupidly)
The food that is produced on an organic farm is identical to food produced on a normal farm except that growing organically requires more acreage to produce the same amount of food. A recent review found no significant difference between the nutritional value of conventional vs. organic food [1]. The only factor in the health section that I am not sure about is the pesticides and herbicides. Obviously both organic and conventional farmers have to use sprays in order to control insects and weeds, but they do use different types. As far as I am aware both types of chemical sprays have to be tested for safety before they can be used. I have seen no evidence that would suggest natural sprays are safer than synthetic ones. I am aware that the natural fungicides used by organic farmers are less effective than those used by convential farmers. This means mycotoxins are found at higher levels in organic cereal products like maize flour [2].
Although it is subjective, in the "street stall" tests that I have seen, people are unable to taste the difference between organic and convential food. I think the idea that organic food tastes better is psychological. I'm willing to grant that food you grow yourself may taste better than food brought in a shop due to the freshness and ability to pick after the food has fully ripened. However, this doesn't extend to a big organic farm vs. a big conventional farm. The food still has to be harvested en masse and transported to various distribution centers. People want the food to taste better so it does. Take a look at this video from about 1:30 onwards: It challenges my conception of bananas
The only thing that I can see organic farming has going for it is that it tries to be more sustainable. I think most people would prefer if all our production was more sustainable. However, many of the claims that are made for organic farming are clearly pseudoscientific, at best.
[1] Organic 'has no health benefits'
[2] Toxin sparks organic scare
Organic farming is basically farming without using synthetic chemicals, fertilisers, or organisms (i.e., GMOs). The idea is to use natural alternatives which are supposedly better in some way. From my point of view organic farming is one big naturalistic fallacy. (*It doesn't refer to C's and H's, stupidly)
The food that is produced on an organic farm is identical to food produced on a normal farm except that growing organically requires more acreage to produce the same amount of food. A recent review found no significant difference between the nutritional value of conventional vs. organic food [1]. The only factor in the health section that I am not sure about is the pesticides and herbicides. Obviously both organic and conventional farmers have to use sprays in order to control insects and weeds, but they do use different types. As far as I am aware both types of chemical sprays have to be tested for safety before they can be used. I have seen no evidence that would suggest natural sprays are safer than synthetic ones. I am aware that the natural fungicides used by organic farmers are less effective than those used by convential farmers. This means mycotoxins are found at higher levels in organic cereal products like maize flour [2].
Although it is subjective, in the "street stall" tests that I have seen, people are unable to taste the difference between organic and convential food. I think the idea that organic food tastes better is psychological. I'm willing to grant that food you grow yourself may taste better than food brought in a shop due to the freshness and ability to pick after the food has fully ripened. However, this doesn't extend to a big organic farm vs. a big conventional farm. The food still has to be harvested en masse and transported to various distribution centers. People want the food to taste better so it does. Take a look at this video from about 1:30 onwards: It challenges my conception of bananas
The only thing that I can see organic farming has going for it is that it tries to be more sustainable. I think most people would prefer if all our production was more sustainable. However, many of the claims that are made for organic farming are clearly pseudoscientific, at best.
[1] Organic 'has no health benefits'
[2] Toxin sparks organic scare