Re: Could atheism survive the discovery of extraterrestrial
I apologize if I misquoted or misinterpreted your words,
all I am saying is that the truth of Christianity is not dependent on whether if we find Aliens or not, this is why I said that the discovery of aliens would be a theologically neutral discovery.
is there anything along these lines that you disagree with?
Sparhafoc said:leroy said:and why would that be a problem for God, or for my religion?
Another bizarre question that doesn't arise from anything I wrote.
What actually happened is that you said the discovery of alien life would be theologically neutral, and my point is that it wouldn't be in the slightest bit theologically neutral (assuming you know your own religion's theology) - I, of course, never suggested it would be a 'problem'.
I really do think I am quite clear in my written word, and I really don't see as you can ignore what I wrote in order to suggest the opposite. I did not say it was a problem, so I am not going to respond to a question asking me why I think it would be a problem. Unless, of course, we're practicing argumentation rather than honestly stating our own opinion?
I could, of course, argue that the discovery of extraterrestrial life would be a problem for Christianity if you want me to? Just let me know what position I can hold that's most convenient for what you want to argue.
leroy said:the truth of Christianity (at least my view) depends on whether if Jesus resurrected or not, finding aliens is simply irrelevant,
Well, Jesus wasn't resurrected because resurrection is a magical fairy tale to convince the illiterate people of the Classical Age that humans were special. They believed it because they had no knowledge of how nature operates, operated under the presupposition that a tinkering overbeing was at work, and the consequent two thousand years have offered not a single jot of evidence of the existence of this alleged being who is everywhere and who tinkers with the laws of the universe.
In other words, I'd put my money on a horse that isn't 2000 years dead and which never had any legs in the first place.
I apologize if I misquoted or misinterpreted your words,
all I am saying is that the truth of Christianity is not dependent on whether if we find Aliens or not, this is why I said that the discovery of aliens would be a theologically neutral discovery.
is there anything along these lines that you disagree with?