• Welcome to League Of Reason Forums! Please read the rules before posting.
    If you are willing and able please consider making a donation to help with site overheads.
    Donations can be made via here

Cassini Death Day

Sparhafoc

Active Member
arg-fallbackName="Sparhafoc"/>
End of Mission: 15 Sep 2017 in just 16days

What a run it's had! 13 years of discoveries that dramatically expanded our knowledge of the Solar System, of the molecular composition of other planets, and of our place in the scheme of things.

https://saturn.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/grand-finale/overview/


That's a day worth celebrating. I'll be taking a day off and, rarely for me, having a few drinks in the many scientists' honour.
 
arg-fallbackName="Deleted member 619"/>
Had to log in to comment on this.

This has been a quite stupendous mission. The sheer numbers involved are spectacular, and it's one of my favourite examples to use in elucidating how science progresses, albeit one that I initially borrowed from a very good friend of ours.

Science deniers will often harp on about how science is constantly changing, generally with little understanding of what form those changes take (or the fact that, far from being a weakness, this is its greatest strength), and this is a beautiful example.

This mission went on a journey of 15x10[sup]11[/sup] kilometres, including four gravitational slingshot manoeuvres, parked within 20 metres of its intended orbit , and all this was done with an incorrect theory described by an incorrect law. The difference between Newtonian gravity and general relativity at such scales and speeds is so small that, even over 15x10[sup]11[/sup] kilometres, the error amounts to 20 metres!

The data provided by this mission have been incredible, and promise to take decades to sort through. One can only describe it as an unparalleled success, and that's without even bothering to compare it to parochial bullshit like deities.

Good stuff.
 
arg-fallbackName="he_who_is_nobody"/>
Beyond everything hackenslash pointed out, Cassini is also one of the dozens of space crafts powered by decaying atoms. We understand this process so well, it powers space craft.
 
arg-fallbackName="Sparhafoc"/>
hackenslash said:
Science deniers will often harp on about how science is constantly changing, generally with little understanding of what form those changes take (or the fact that, far from being a weakness, this is its greatest strength), and this is a beautiful example.

It's the kind of canard that shows they're running in autopilot. Of course science keeps 'changing' - because it's actually discovering and amassing knowledge that we didn't possess before. No human process or method has ever even got close to the knowledge-generation of science.


hackenslash said:
This mission went on a journey of 15x10[sup]11[/sup] kilometres, including four gravitational slingshot manoeuvres, parked within 20 metres of its intended orbit , and all this was done with an incorrect theory described by an incorrect law. The difference between Newtonian gravity and general relativity at such scales and speeds is so small that, even over 15x10[sup]11[/sup] kilometres, the error amounts to 20 metres!

Nicely put! The relativity of wrong.


hackenslash said:
The data provided by this mission have been incredible, and promise to take decades to sort through. One can only describe it as an unparalleled success, and that's without even bothering to compare it to parochial bullshit like deities.

There can be no comparison: science broadens our horizons and puts those horizons into our grasp, while religion directs us ever deeper into our belly buttons hypnotizing us to believe that we already know everything we need to.
 
arg-fallbackName="Sparhafoc"/>
he_who_is_nobody said:
Beyond everything hackenslash pointed out, Cassini is also one of the dozens of space crafts powered by decaying atoms. We understand this process so well, it powers space craft.

:lol:

But but but....

;)

To keep this thread free of idiocy, I'll add a source of NASA's explanation to that:

https://saturn.jpl.nasa.gov/system/downloadable_items/288_power.pdf
RTGs are lightweight, compact spacecraft power systems that are extraordinarily reliable. RTGs are not nuclear reactors and have no moving parts. They use neither fission nor fusion processes to produce energy. Instead, they provide power through the natural radioactive decay of plutonium (mostly Pu-238, a non-weapons-grade isotope). The heat generated by this natural process is changed into electricity by solid-state thermoelectric converters
 
arg-fallbackName="Sparhafoc"/>
http://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-41222282
The international Cassini spacecraft at Saturn has executed the course correction that will send it to destruction at the end of the week.

The probe flew within 120,000km of the giant moon Titan on Monday - an encounter that bent its trajectory just enough to put it on a collision path with the ringed planet.

Nothing can now stop the death plunge in Saturn's atmosphere on Friday.

Cassini will be torn to pieces as it heads down towards the clouds.

Its components will melt and be dispersed through the planet's gases.
 
arg-fallbackName="ldmitruk"/>
It would be cool if they got some camera shots of Saturn's atmosphere before Cassini breaks up.
 
arg-fallbackName="Sparhafoc"/>
/cue deep philosophizing

So does one celebrate at 11:55:06 GMT when the radio signal goes dead?

Or does one account for the speed of light and celebrate an hour and a half earlier?

Please submit explanations in triplicate.
 
arg-fallbackName="ldmitruk"/>
Sparhafoc said:
/cue deep philosophizing

So does one celebrate at 11:55:06 GMT when the radio signal goes dead?

Or does one account for the speed of light and celebrate an hour and a half earlier?

Please submit explanations in triplicate.

Half an hour later in Newfoundland. :lol:

An interesting conundrum. I would say celebrate both, you get double drinks that way.
 
arg-fallbackName="Sparhafoc"/>
ldmitruk said:
Half an hour later in Newfoundland. :lol:

An interesting conundrum. I would say celebrate both, you get double drinks that way.


1.5 hours of toasting, and I think I'll be ready to plummet to fiery doom into a gas giant.
 
arg-fallbackName="Visaki"/>
I've already seen the first claims that Cassini actually doesn't exist or NASA is hiding something because we didn't get a live video feed of it plunging into the Saturnian atmosphere. People are silly.

Anyways, RIP to one of the most successful space mission of the last decade.
 
Back
Top