• Welcome to League Of Reason Forums! Please read the rules before posting.
    If you are willing and able please consider making a donation to help with site overheads.
    Donations can be made via here

A sci-fi novel I'm working on

g-off

New Member
arg-fallbackName="g-off"/>
This is the first chapter of a novel I'm working on. tell me what you think of it, and please, be honest.
Chapter 1
Death

Jacob Krieger despised the smell of napalm, in the morning or otherwise. He'd smelled more of it in the seventeen years he'd been alive than most soldiers do in their entire lifetimes, but it never got any less sickening. Perhaps it wasn't the smell so much as it was the way his brain automatically associated it with the hideous screams of"¦ no, it'd be best to derail that particular train of thought. Regardless of the cause, the fact of the matter was that the smell of burnt or burning napalm left a nauseous feeling in the pit of his stomach that lingered long after he'd left the battlefield, not that he was going to be leaving anytime soon.

Jacob had a mission to perform, and unfortunately that mission entailed stepping over the charred bodies strewn across the streets, past the remains of those people's houses, burnt to a crisp and bathed in the light of early morning, to confirm the termination of a particularly slippery target. Jacob couldn't see how anyone could have eluded the blaze of white flames that had engulfed the small industrial revolution era town, but orders were orders and aside from that the target was a-

"Shit!"

Jacob blurted out the expletive as a blazing 5-ton truck flew at him out of a nearby alleyway. Acting mostly on instinct, he quickly whipped out his blade and cleaved the flaming wreck cleanly in two. The two halves of the truck missed him by inches, the flames licking at his midnight black cloak as they flew past.

Jacob made his way toward the alley, taunting his quarry as he moved; "You must want to be caught, Jackson. I know that you're nowhere near stupid enough to believe that you could kill me like that."

His mark responded in a thick Brooklyn accent "Back da hell off, Krieger, I'm not goin' back wit 'chu!"

"I'm not here to take you back. Brass can't risk having a potential turncoat walking around with all the juicy secrets you have in your head."

For a while there was silence, then, in a shaky voice, came the reply.

"You mean dey sen 'chu-"

"To kill you, yes."

"And there's no way you could-"

"Just let you go? You know my reputation, Jackson, I've never missed a target, and I'm not ending that streak with a traitor like you."

"Well, if dat's da way it's gonna be, den I guess I'll jus hafta kill ya."

With this, Robert Jackson jumped from the darkened alleyway, ready to crush Krieger's skull with his powerful telekinetic abilities. He looked around for a moment, trying to discern his enemy's location. Unfortunately, as Krieger's skeletal hands wrapped around his neck, Jackson realized that his enemy had other plans.

"How da hell?"

"I threw my voice. In my line of work it's a good trick to know."

"Goddamn phasers! I should have"¦"


"Well you didn't, and now..."

There was a crackling noise and the smell of burning ozone, then Jackson convulsed and went stiff and his hair stood on end. His heart stopped, his brain shut down, and Robert Jackson ceased to be. Jacob put a finger to his headset and spoke.

"Agent Delta to dispatch; Target has been eliminated"

"Good job, Delta," said the smooth, calming voice on the other end, "Retrieve the head for scanning and return to base."

Jacob sighed and drew his blade. Psycomorphic energy flowed into it through his fleshless arm and the edge morphed and became serrated. As Jacob prepared to get to work the sickening smell of napalm mixed with the knowledge of what he was about to do made him feel decidedly nauseous.

"I hate doing this. I'll bet Aaron never has to put up with this shit."



Aaron Krieger never did have too put up with that shit. In the comfortable cockpit of his destroyer class mech, Ares, the short, dark-haired nineteen year old didn't have to worry about unpleasant things like decapitations. In fact, he didn't to worry about much other than torching stuff. As the hulking crimson robot made the slow march through the field toward the location of the terrorist base, he opened the mission dossier on his view screen and re-read it.

Outline:

At 1600 hours yesterday Sgt. second class Robert Jackson went AWOL. This is particularly urgent for two reasons. Firstly, the Sergeant was in charge of testing for a top-secret new weapon in development by the UR military. Secondly, agents operating within the Vaaldaran borders have reported an individual who matches the sergeant's description heading for the headquarters of suspected terrorist organization Next Step, a group of Xenomorphs who promote the belief that Xenocite induced mutations represent the next level of human evolution. The organization claims to be nothing more than a group of peaceful activists, however, covert investigations have shown links between the group and violent attacks on various organizations promoting the superiority of humans and even a few promoting equality among the races. We have good reason to suspect that if the terrorists gain access to the technology they will use it against innocent civilians. It is imperative that we stop this from happening.

Mission Details:

This is a three tiered operation. Agents tracking Jackson have reported that he has disappeared somewhere in the town of Alvez, thirty kilometres from Next Step's headquarters. Jackson is a powerful Telekinetic and a sensitive, meaning that he will be able to detect the presence of anyone following him. Because of this it will be almost impossible to track him down, and thus we must use a strategy with a wide area of effect. Agent Upsilon will torch the town utilizing the Ares mech, an unfortunate but necessary step. The town is small and most of the buildings date back to the industrial revolution, so burning it down should prove to be easy. Following that, agent Delta will enter the town in uniform and confirm the target's elimination. He will then retrieve the target's head and bring it back for a brainscan. If the scan confirms that Jackson was indeed intending to assist the terrorists, the Ares will move on their base. Flying is not permitted in this mission as it may give the enemy an early warning. The goal in this case is the complete destruction of Next Step. It is vital that this mission be kept a secret from the Vaaldaran government, as it could be considered an act of war if discovered. To this effect, there must not be a single witness left over. Take no prisoners. If any operative spots a live civilian during the mission, they are to kill on sight.


Not the most pleasant mission that Aaron had been on in the past few months, but if the men upstairs deemed it necessary, it was necessary. Besides, Aaron enjoyed a bit of army sanctioned wanton destruction once in a while, and even if a few hundred civvies got caught in the fray, they were saving countless more by keeping the weapon out of the hands of the terrorists.

The Ares continued to move. It was a truly majestic machine. It had a dragon motif to its design, most obvious in the head, which was modelled with a human-like face within the mouth of a dragon head, and was coloured in black and crimson. The build of the mech was vaguely humanoid, though it was so deformed as to look almost cartoony. Its forearms were much bigger than its upper arms and each arm was specialized for a different purpose. The right had large claws equipped with molecular cutters, blades made up of concentrated photons that were capable of cutting at a molecular level. The left was outfitted with a multipurpose cannon that could be used to fire either lasers or to spray chemicals. Its legs were similarly dimensioned, though they served for little more than locomotion. On the back was mounted a large cannon capable of firing a powerful energy beam. The cannon rested on top of an interchangeable tank designed to carry various liquids, and folded up on either side was a large pair of metal wings.

Aaron stopped at the designated wait point - a spot behind a hill about half a kilometre from the terrorist base. It was the closest he could get without being picked up by radar or spotted by a guard. He activated the Ares cloaking matrix, and the molecule thick layer of nanomachines that coated his mech each collaborated to project an image that created the illusion of empty space. He was completely invisible so long as he didn't move and nobody paid too much attention to the two patches of seemingly inexplicably flattened grass where his mech's feet were.

He stayed there for a good ten minutes before the familiar beeping of his communicator reverberated through the Ares cockpit. He switched on the radio and was greeted by the smooth voice of the squad 4-H dispatcher.

"Agent Upsilon, the scan was a negative. Repeat, the scan was a negative. The terrorists are not involved with Jackson. Pull out."

Aaron sighed. He had been looking forward to maiming a few terrorists before lunch.

"Roger that, I am re-"

Just then, a rocket ripped through the field. It seemed that someone had in paid too much attention to the two patches of inexplicably
flattened grass. Apparently, that someone had a mech of their own. The rocket passed over the top of Ares' head by about a foot, frying a patch of nanobots with its tail. Aaron had a bad feeling that the next rocket wouldn't miss.

"Shit! That is a negative. I have been engaged by an enemy unit and am returning fire."

As he said this, Aaron deactivated his cloak and fired a high concentration energy beam at the enemy mech. The pulsating blue beam tore the enemy's cheap, mass produced mech to shreds in a matter of seconds. As its bulky rectangular frame fell to the ground in a ruined heap he heard shouts and a squad of around 50 heavily armed xenomorphs came at him from over the hill, guns blazing. A few were using telekinetic powers to hurl debris or attempt in vain to pick up the Ares. One of the stronger looking titans of the group was effortlessly carrying what appeared to be an anti-armour railgun, and not too far off could be heard the telltale clanking feet of at least five more mecha moving to join the fray. To top it off, the Ares energy reserves had been depleted by the cannon, so all of the weapons were temporarily offline.

Aaron grinned. This was more like it.
 
arg-fallbackName="nasher168"/>
Good writing style. It got across the stuff that was going on quite well, although I couldn't tell what kind of a future it is supposed to be. That might be intentional-perhaps you would outline that more in a later instalment? That said, I got an image of a government gone absolutely mad on it's anti-terror policies, justifying itself by claiming to save more lives than it takes. Is that what you intended?
 
arg-fallbackName="scalyblue"/>
g-off said:
This is the first chapter of a novel I'm working on. tell me what you think of it, and please, be honest.
Oh, I'm not sure you really mean that.

Hello there, Scaly at your service!

This will be an inline critique and I will crit as I read.

My critique of this work will touch on grammar and structure, but that isn't why you came here, is it?
I'm going to critique your style from the perspective of a reader of Strunk and White, however my main focus is the elimination of fridge logic, plot holes and blatant wallbangers. I'm the person who asks how anybody heard CF Kane's last words in Citizen Kane if he died alone. I will also point out any blatant factual errors that have no handwaves to suspend disbelief; there will also be a continuing quest against said bookisms

I am very opinionated and will likely provide examples by rewriting snippets of your text.
I am not trying to hijack your story.
I am not trying to prove myself better.
I am just furnishing examples for your consideration.

Lastly, my criticisms are directed at your work, not you. Even the books I treasure the most have 1 star Amazon.com ratings, and those ratings don't come from people who are actively attempting to tear something down to its foundation so that it can be rebuilt stronger and better.

Well, let's get started!

Chapter 1
Death

Jacob Krieger despised the smell of napalm, in the morning or otherwise. He'd smelled more of it in the seventeen years he'd been alive than most soldiers do in their entire lifetimes, but it never got any less sickening. Perhaps it wasn't the smell so much as it was the way his brain automatically associated it with the hideous screams of"¦ no, it'd be best to derail that particular train of thought. Are we in Jacob's POV? Are these his thoughts? Because it's written from 3'rd person omni, we have information that Jacob won't have but we're still talking about as if these are Jaboc's thoughts. Is he god? If he's not god, you need to recast basically this entire paragraph. Regardless of the cause, the fact of the matter was that the smell of burnt or burning napalm left a nauseous feeling in the pit of his stomach that lingered long after he'd left the battlefield, not that he was going to be leaving anytime soon.

Let's sing the clumsy exposition song here. Wow, Jacob despised the smell of napalm because he'd smelled more of it in seventeen years? And he's been alive than most soldiers do? And it never got less sickening? And perhaps it wasn't the smell? Perhaps it was the way his brain automatically associated it with hideous screams of...screaming? Why do I need to know all of this this right now, how is it relevant to the story, and why are you telling it in this manner. Too much telling, way too much telling.

Jacob had a mission to perform, and unfortunately that mission entailed stepping over the charred bodies strewn across the streets, past the remains of those people's houses, burnt to a crisp and bathed in the light of early morning, to confirm the termination of a particularly slippery target. Jacob couldn't see how anyone could have eluded the blaze of white flames that had engulfed the small industrial revolution era town, but orders were orders and aside from that the target was a-

More heavy-handed exposition. You may as well write "WAR = BAD" on an anvil and fling it at your reader's head. Not only that, if he's been a fighter for seventeen years wouldn't he be a bit more acclimated to the environment and be considering tactical outlooks on things? A soldier can't see bodies as bodies if he wants to live, he has to see them as obstructions.
Consider this, and not so much the wording as the flavor and the order of presentation of facts. The subtraction of :

Following his objective lead Jacob to a gutted, industrial revolution era town. He swallowed the flavor of vomit when the oppressive stink of napalm struck him. Seventeen years hadn't been enough to unwind that scent from the screams evoked from his memory. He let his gaze pass over the charred shapes strewn about the shattered pavement of the main avenue, pushing down that tiny voice that wept for them. The gutted houses were more important, now. His target could be in any of those sorrowful, darkened windows, behind any door. A man needed killing. Jacob had a mission to do.



"Shit!" Did a character's dialog just interject with your omnipresent narration? Tell me that did not just happen. This is what we call breaking the fourth wall.

Jacob blurted out the expletive as a blazing 5-ton truck flew at him out of a nearby alleyway. Acting mostly on instinct, he quickly whipped out his blade and cleaved the flaming wreck cleanly in two. The two halves of the truck missed him by inches, the flames licking at his midnight black cloak as they flew past. We have Five, count them, Five Marty Stu warning signs here. First thing's first, if the perspective is omni, this is fine, but the way you wrote this speaks of perspective issues. Is jacob the POV character? If so, how does he know how heavy the truck weighs, whether he acted mostly on instinct?

Jacob made his way toward the alley, taunting his quarry as he moved; "You must want to be caught, Jackson. I know that you're nowhere near stupid enough to believe that you could kill me like that." Oh yes, throwing a flaming five ton chunk of steel at him couldn't possibly kill our protagonist, he's just *that* good.

His mark responded in a thick Brooklyn accent "Back da hell off, Krieger, I'm not goin' back wit 'chu!" Avoid doing this, at all. Stephen King does it, and when he does it it's damned annoying. When you do it, it will get you tossed in the slush pile. Also, the phonetic forms you use do not indicate a brooklyn accent.

"I'm not here to take you back. Brass can't risk having a potential turncoat walking around with all the juicy secrets you have in your head." If you can cut a truck in half with a sword, why are you bothering to have this conversation? If your mission is to kill him, why not convince him you are taking him back and then just kill him? Woudn't that be easier than flinging heavy shit at each other?

For a while there was silence, then, in a shaky voice, came the reply. A while? That speaks from a character's point of view. A while is subjective.

"You mean dey sen 'chu-"

"To kill you, yes."

"And there's no way you could-"

"Just let you go? You know my reputation, Jackson, I've never missed a target, and I'm not ending that streak with a traitor like you." More exposition. This dialog seems rather trite if you ask me. If these are supposed to be two old friends or compartriots, I am not seeing it at all.

"Well, if dat's da way it's gonna be, den I guess I'll jus hafta kill ya." Oh, yes, because that's something somebody would really say before killing.

With this, Robert Jackson jumped from the darkened alleyway, ready to crush Krieger's skull with his powerful telekinetic abilities. He looked around for a moment, trying to discern his enemy's location. Unfortunately, as Krieger's skeletal hands wrapped around his neck, Jackson realized that his enemy had other plans. If he has powerful telekenetic abilities why not just drop a building on him? Or five? Or get to a point where you can see him and just telekensis his body up about a thousand feet into the air and just let him drop? Or wrap a telekenetic shell around his head that air can't penetrate? I mean, wtf? I have super powers AND i'm some sort of soldier, it's a good idea to run out into the middle of a street without clearing the area, creating covering fire, or even looking around a corner first.

"How da hell?" Yes, he's saying this with skeletal hands wrapped around his neck.

"I threw my voice. In my line of work it's a good trick to know." Throwing your voice is a misdirection technique that only works if your mark can see you, unless it was a supernatural abillity or a type of technology, in which case that should be handwaved.

"Goddamn phasers! I should have"¦" Phaser is a term from star trek referring to PHASed Energy Rectification. If your phasers are people who phase out of reality, or something along those lines, it needs to be handwaved first otherwise you are going to step on star trek.


"Well you didn't, and now..." This is cliche.

There was a crackling noise and the smell of burning ozone, then Jackson convulsed and went stiff and his hair stood on end. His heart stopped, his brain shut down, and Robert Jackson ceased to be. Jacob put a finger to his headset and spoke. Wouldn't it have been easier just to shoot him? If he had telekenetic abilities wouldn't he be able to just break the handhold on him? Or slice his assailant's head off with a blade of focused air?

"Agent Delta to dispatch; Target has been eliminated" Yes, because when somebody's sent to kill a rogue, or a defector, this is announced to normal dispach.

"Good job, Delta," said the smooth, calming voice on the other end, "Retrieve the head for scanning and return to base." If they already know that he had secrets, why need his head? What is there to scan? Once brain activity stops it stops and you have neuron soup. If brain activity didn't stop, then wouldn't his telekenetic ability still function?

Jacob sighed and drew his blade. Psycomorphic energy flowed into it through his fleshless arm and the edge morphed and became serrated. As Jacob prepared to get to work the sickening smell of napalm mixed with the knowledge of what he was about to do made him feel decidedly nauseous.
He has skeleton arms and can handle 'psycomorphic' energy and finds distaste in chopping somebody's head off? and he's not going to use a clean edge, he's going to use a serrated one?


"I hate doing this. I'll bet Aaron never has to put up with this shit." Who is he talking to? Himself?



Aaron Krieger never did have too put up with that shit. In the comfortable cockpit of his destroyer class mech, Ares, the short, dark-haired nineteen year old didn't have to worry about unpleasant things like decapitations. In fact, he didn't to worry about much other than torching stuff. As the hulking crimson robot made the slow march through the field toward the location of the terrorist base, he opened the mission dossier on his view screen and re-read it. Super duper scene transition without warning. Well that works, I guess. What's a mech, what's destroyer class? Am I supposed to get pictures of these things in my head, becuase you certainly don't describe them. A robot is autonomous, but it's not? What field? What terorrist base? If he's in a mech, which I would imagine is considered something like a tank, where's the rest of his battalion? If one side has these, why don't the terrorists have them, or appropriate countermeasures? Is this supposed to be a bipedal robot? Couldn't it be defeated then, by a trip wire?

Cluing you in, if bipedal tanks were better for combat, we would have already invented them. They're not.


Outline:

At 1600 hours yesterday Sgt. second class Robert Jackson went AWOL. This is particularly urgent for two reasons. Firstly, the Sergeant was in charge of testing for a top-secret new weapon in development by the UR military. Secondly, agents operating within the Vaaldaran borders have reported an individual who matches the sergeant's description heading for the headquarters of suspected terrorist organization Next Step, a group of Xenomorphs who promote the belief that Xenocite induced mutations represent the next level of human evolution. The organization claims to be nothing more than a group of peaceful activists, however, covert investigations have shown links between the group and violent attacks on various organizations promoting the superiority of humans and even a few promoting equality among the races. We have good reason to suspect that if the terrorists gain access to the technology they will use it against innocent civilians. It is imperative that we stop this from happening. More pointless exposition, this paragraph is also TL;DR and throws wayyyyy too much shit at you at once.

Mission Details:

This is a three tiered operation. Agents tracking Jackson have reported that he has disappeared somewhere in the town of Alvez, thirty kilometres from Next Step's headquarters. Jackson is a powerful Telekinetic and a sensitive, meaning that he will be able to detect the presence of anyone following him. Because of this it will be almost impossible to track him down, and thus we must use a strategy with a wide area of effect. Agent Upsilon will torch the town utilizing the Ares mech, an unfortunate but necessary step. The town is small and most of the buildings date back to the industrial revolution, so burning it down should prove to be easy. Following that, agent Delta will enter the town in uniform and confirm the target's elimination. He will then retrieve the target's head and bring it back for a brainscan. If the scan confirms that Jackson was indeed intending to assist the terrorists, the Ares will move on their base. Flying is not permitted in this mission as it may give the enemy an early warning. The goal in this case is the complete destruction of Next Step. It is vital that this mission be kept a secret from the Vaaldaran government, as it could be considered an act of war if discovered. To this effect, there must not be a single witness left over. Take no prisoners. If any operative spots a live civilian during the mission, they are to kill on sight.
More of the same. Too much going on here, too much infodump.

Not the most pleasant mission that Aaron had been on in the past few months, but if the men upstairs deemed it necessary, it was necessary. Besides, Aaron enjoyed a bit of army sanctioned wanton destruction once in a while, and even if a few hundred civvies got caught in the fray, they were saving countless more by keeping the weapon out of the hands of the terrorists.

The Ares continued to move. It was a truly majestic machine. It had a dragon motif to its design, most obvious in the head, which was modelled with a human-like face within the mouth of a dragon head, and was coloured in black and crimson. The build of the mech was vaguely humanoid, though it was so deformed as to look almost cartoony. Its forearms were much bigger than its upper arms and each arm was specialized for a different purpose. The right had large claws equipped with molecular cutters, blades made up of concentrated photons that were capable of cutting at a molecular level. The left was outfitted with a multipurpose cannon that could be used to fire either lasers or to spray chemicals. Its legs were similarly dimensioned, though they served for little more than locomotion. On the back was mounted a large cannon capable of firing a powerful energy beam. The cannon rested on top of an interchangeable tank designed to carry various liquids, and folded up on either side was a large pair of metal wings.

Aaron stopped at the designated wait point - a spot behind a hill about half a kilometre from the terrorist base. It was the closest he could get without being picked up by radar or spotted by a guard. He activated the Ares cloaking matrix, and the molecule thick layer of nanomachines that coated his mech each collaborated to project an image that created the illusion of empty space. He was completely invisible so long as he didn't move and nobody paid too much attention to the two patches of seemingly inexplicably flattened grass where his mech's feet were.

He stayed there for a good ten minutes before the familiar beeping of his communicator reverberated through the Ares cockpit. He switched on the radio and was greeted by the smooth voice of the squad 4-H dispatcher.

"Agent Upsilon, the scan was a negative. Repeat, the scan was a negative. The terrorists are not involved with Jackson. Pull out."

Aaron sighed. He had been looking forward to maiming a few terrorists before lunch.

"Roger that, I am re-"

Just then, a rocket ripped through the field. It seemed that someone had in paid too much attention to the two patches of inexplicably
flattened grass. Apparently, that someone had a mech of their own. The rocket passed over the top of Ares' head by about a foot, frying a patch of nanobots with its tail. Aaron had a bad feeling that the next rocket wouldn't miss.

"Shit! That is a negative. I have been engaged by an enemy unit and am returning fire."

As he said this, Aaron deactivated his cloak and fired a high concentration energy beam at the enemy mech. The pulsating blue beam tore the enemy's cheap, mass produced mech to shreds in a matter of seconds. As its bulky rectangular frame fell to the ground in a ruined heap he heard shouts and a squad of around 50 heavily armed xenomorphs came at him from over the hill, guns blazing. A few were using telekinetic powers to hurl debris or attempt in vain to pick up the Ares. One of the stronger looking titans of the group was effortlessly carrying what appeared to be an anti-armour railgun, and not too far off could be heard the telltale clanking feet of at least five more mecha moving to join the fray. To top it off, the Ares energy reserves had been depleted by the cannon, so all of the weapons were temporarily offline.

Aaron grinned. This was more like it.Okay, the entire second 'part' of this was nothing but a thinly veiled infodump. Infodump = bad. You want to show these things, not tell them--spread it out.

Right now you're narrating a storyline. This is not how to write fiction. People don't read ficiton to see big sweeping craps, they read it to connect with a character. Your character needs to be something more than a puppet for all of these cool things you want to show people. If you have any questions feel free to reply.
 
Back
Top