I've been following along with the recent controversy in the blogosphere regarding those annoyed with the gnu atheists. I'm not really sure what their beef is or why they are so annoyed. Jerry Coyne suggested it could be jealousy. Richard Dawkins et al are relatively new on the scene nor are they making incredibly new arguments. But they are the authors of best-selling books, something which the old school atheists can only dream of. Ophilia Benson though it may have something to do with religious studies academics running into student with dismissive attitudes towards religions. If you are a lecturer and so of your students are not interested in the fine details of your subject it could get quick annoying.
My own take is similar but I think it is the no-nonsense approach of the gnus that is annoying the old-school atheists. No longer is engaging in the minutia of religious argumentation considered worth-while. Religion is obviously nonsense (and not good for you to boot) now let's get on with the more important questions of how to treat each other and live fulfilling lives.
Has anyone heard other reasons for why the gnus are so annoying? Or do you have your own takes?
My own take is similar but I think it is the no-nonsense approach of the gnus that is annoying the old-school atheists. No longer is engaging in the minutia of religious argumentation considered worth-while. Religion is obviously nonsense (and not good for you to boot) now let's get on with the more important questions of how to treat each other and live fulfilling lives.
Has anyone heard other reasons for why the gnus are so annoying? Or do you have your own takes?